After posting
"Who Are the Good Guys", I had several conversations with guy friends of mine and even The Dude. A couple of the comments mentioned the same topic that came up in these other conversations.
They argue that men can't be the good guy, because the good guy never gets the girl. They insist that we always want the bad guy.
For starters, there's no denying that this happens. There are plenty of women out there who say they want a good guy, but don't acknowledge the ones right in front of them. There are plenty of women who fall for the bad boy tactics, and cry over and over again that they don't understand why they can't find a good man.
Those women honestly frustrate me, because they make it so hard to convince men to be
good guys.
Even so, I will argue to my grave that being a good guy is still the best option. I really believe that good guys don't finish last but instead end up happier than bad guys - because they definitely can get the girl. Not just any girl - the right girl.
Here's why:
1. There's a difference between a guy with a little "bad boy" in him and an asshole. I think this is an important distinction to make, and maybe one that a lot of women don't realize when we say we want a bad boy. We don't want an asshole. We don't want a guy who doesn't call us back or want to introduce us to his friends. But some of us - probably most of us - do want a guy with a little
edge, and I think that's actually more about desiring a certain level of masculinity than it is about wanting a
bad boy. Some women like a man with a beard, because it might suggest he's a little rugged or a bit of a rebel (especially in straight-laced DC). Some women like a man with a tattoo here or there. Some women want a man who just acts tough, because he's a man. Some women want a man who can fix things with his bare hands. Sure, there are some undesirable gender stereotypes there, but it's also true in a lot of cases. All of these are qualities that might typically suggest a "bad boy", but they definitely don't mean we also want him to treat us like crap. There's a huge difference.
2. Women who chase assholes don't know themselves yet. I feel very strongly about this. Women who keep going back to guys who don't treat them with respect, guys who expect them to answer a booty call at the drop of a hat just to spend time with them, guys who don't flatter them or make them feel special - those women are either immature, insecure, as yet unsure that they deserve better, or fatally damaged. Normal, well-adjusted, mature women who know how to have healthy relationships do not chase assholes.
If men just want a physical relationship, these women are easy pickings. It's easy to treat them like crap, knowing they will keep coming back for more. Maybe the most disappointing reality of dating in a time where casual sex is common is that men know this - some men manipulate those women to their advantage, and use them to get what they want and move on.
One of the truest chick-flick quotes I've ever heard (if that's not an oxymoron) was this: "Every woman has the exact love life she wants." I think there is a lot of truth to that statement. We should all try to remember it when we go on and on about bad guys treating us badly. We want a loving relationship? Let's change our behavior and go after a good guy for a change.
But for the good guy who truly does want to find a relationship and a person to spend their life with - you don't want a relationship with those damaged, immature, or insecure women who chase assholes anyway. You want the normal, well-adjusted woman who is ready for a healthy relationship. And that woman wants a good guy.
3. We don't want a "Yes Man". We do want you to treat us well, and we do want you to realize that we are a catch, but that doesn't mean we want you to just roll over and kiss the ground we walk on. We want an equal, not a puppy dog. And while we all enjoy being chased, we also each enjoy the act of chasing, at least a little.
You can do this without being a bad guy. It doesn't mean that you act aloof and ignore us for three days. Does that get under our skin? Sure. But all it does is initiate the game-playing, and too much game-playing is a bad thing.
So how do you get us to chase you without becoming the bad guy? Just be flirty and a little mysterious. Pay attention to the vibes you're getting from her and just go with the flow.
4. Strike a balance. This goes hand-in-hand with avoiding the yes man behavior. Yes, you want to communicate and show the girl that you're interested. But you don't want to go overboard with that. A simple text the day after a date to say that you had a good time and are looking forward to seeing her again can go a long way. Sending multiple unanswered texts or emails and smothering her will backfire. That's when you move from good guy to chump.
5. Don't get into the Friend Zone. You don't get into the friend zone simply because you're being a good guy. This is an argument a lot of unlucky-in-love good guys like to make. They claim that they'll never get the girl because they always get placed in the friend zone. Nine times out of ten, you're getting put in the friend zone because you didn't man up. Don't act like a friend - act like a man who's pursuing and courting a woman he wants to be with. Be a gentleman, but
pursue her.
Kiss the girl! (You'd be surprised how many times this is the problem.) We all want to be chased - you do, too - just do it, still be a good guy, and you'll get the girl.
6. Know that you deserve to be treated just as well as we want you to treat us. I don't think I was clear enough about this in my previous post. Everything I said there goes both ways. The woman should respond to your efforts at communication and date planning and also initiate them herself. She should feel lucky to be on a date with you and work to impress your friends when she meets them. Confidence is sexy. Like I said before, we want an equal - not a man who tries to manipulate or control our emotions and not a yes man.
The good guy with an edge is the Goldilocks of the dating world ... juuuuuust right.
And finally, remember that chemistry matters. You might do everything right and she might do everything right and it still might ... not ... work. This doesn't mean that you should go back to being a bad guy. It just means that you weren't right for each other. Keep looking - the good guy gets the girl. I promise.